
Stirring the Plot
by Daryl Wood Gerber
Series: Cookbook Nook Mystery #3
Series Rating:
Published by Berkley on September 30, 2014
Setting: California
Genres: Cozy Culinary Holiday Mystery
Pages: 304
Format: Kindle, Paperback
Goodreads
BookBub
Get Your Copy at: Amazon, Book Depository
Also in this series: Sifting Through Clues, Final Sentence
Halloween in Crystal Cove, California, is a big deal, involving a spooky soiree where the Winsome Witches, a fund-raising group, gather to open up their purse strings and trade superstitions. But party magicians, fortune-tellers, and herbalists are only the beginning of this recipe for disaster…
Jenna Hart has packed The Cookbook Nook chock-full of everything from ghostly texts to witchy potions in anticipation of the annual fund-raiser luncheon. But there’s one unexpected addition to the menu: murder.
When the Head Priestess of the Winsome Witches is found dead under mysterious circumstances, there’s no logical answer and plenty of blame to go around. With her aunt, Vera, unable to call on her ability to foresee the future, Jenna will have to use more than just sleight of hand and a few magic tricks to conjure up the truth…
Stirring the Plot by Daryl Wood Gerber has Jenna Hart solving another mystery.
Will Jenna solve this mystery before Halloween Night?
Jenna Hart
Jenna Hart seems to be having a wonderful time back in her hometown of Crystal Cove. She seems to be moving on from her husband’s untimely passing; she has a wonderful orange kitten named Tigger, and she has a thriving business with her aunt Vera. Jenna is getting into the Halloween spirit and loving the activities that the Winsome Witches have planned. I honestly don’t blame her; they all sounded like so much fun.
I think Jenna is an awesome sleuth, and she always solves the mysteries in the nick of time. Jenna and I would probably be friends if we ever met. Even if I only solve mysteries by reading them, not in real life.
The Mystery
Jenna Hart doesn’t find the body in this book; instead, her aunt Vera and the rest of the Winsome Witches find their High Priestess deceased at her house. I felt bad for Jenna as she tried so hard not to get involved in this mystery, but her aunt insisted they investigate. Jenna does have a knack, though, for getting people to talk around her. I got the person who did it a couple of chapters before Jenna did, though not the why.
Five Stars
My rating for Stirring the Plot by Daryl Wood Gerber is five stars. I recommend this series, and even if you don’t read it in order, Ms. Gerber makes each book a standalone mystery. I love it when authors do that. I am loving this earlier version of Jenna Hart and discovering how she became the one I read in my first book of this series.
Ms. Gerber has some delicious recipes in the back of this book. I love that each recipe has a note from a character before it. The recipes are Witchy Woman Cocktail, Simple Syrup, Dark Chocolate Laced with Cayenne Pepper, Sunflower Seed Brittle, French Silk Fudge Cake, Pumpkin Pecan Chocolate Bonbons, Katie’s Caramel Popcorn Balls, Pumpkin Maple Syrup Cheesecake, and Maple Pecan Sauce.

Cookbook Nook Mysteries

Thank you for dropping by! I hope you enjoyed this review of Stirring the Plot by Daryl Wood Gerber.
Until the next time,

Happy Reading!

Reading this book contributed to these challenges:
- 2026 Cloak and Dagger
- 2026 Craving the Cozies
- 2026 Cruisin' thru the Cozies
- 2026 Finish the Series RC
- 2026 Goodreads RC
- 2026 Medical Examiner Mystery RC
- 2026 Six Shooter RC
- 2026 TBR Jar RC
- 2026 Traveling the World



















Leave a Reply