Garage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora’s Box Murders

Posted September 15, 2026 by karenbaron in Book to Movie, Movie Review, Mystery, Review / 0 Comments

Format: T.V. Movie

Mysteries on the ScreenGarage Sale Mysteries_ The Pandora’s Box MurdersGarage Sale Mysteries: The Pandora’s Box Murders

Network:                       Hallmark Mystery

Series Number:         12

Director:                    Neill Fearnley

Teleplay by:              Kraig Wenman

Plot Summary:

Garage sale guru and amateur sleuth Jennifer Shannon agrees to appear on a new reality TV series. During the show she comes in contact with a mysterious puzzle box, in which the box’s now-deceased creator may have placed the clue to her killer. When the dead woman’s daughter-in-law is found dead just a few days later, Jennifer’s curiosity once again places her in harm’s way as she embarks on her own unorthodox investigation of the murders.

Divider

My Rating:

five-stars

My Thoughts:

Dani talks Jennifer into appearing on a new reality TV series that will feature their shop for an episode, along with one of the antiques they are working on. Dani and Jen end up having fun while doing this whole thing. A woman stops in with a puzzle box for Jen to open, but doesn’t want to be on the show, as her in-laws wouldn’t want their name getting leaked out.

I have to say that this movie had me a bit stumped. Solving the murder was a lot harder since the puzzle box, which can’t be opened, is a big clue. Jen takes things in stride and ends up helping out the police to figure out who did it. Jason, Hannah, and Logan each have their own things to deal with. Hannah meets a new guy she likes, Logan ends up needing to raise money for the damages he accidentally caused while driving his dad’s car, and Jason ends up helping both kids by being a shoulder to cry on when they need to talk things out with him.

I liked this movie even with my stepdad announcing with each new piece of evidence that this certain person is the killer or that one. He ended up being wrong, while my mom and I ended up being right. Okay, it’s more that we each had pieces, and we all ended up being right. It’s fun revisiting these mysteries and getting geared up for the new one coming out soon.

Divider

The Pandora's Box Murders Pics

Divider

Cast:

Lori Loughlin (Jennifer Shannon)
Sarah Strange (Dani)
Steve Bacic (Jason Shannon)
Connor Stanhope (Logan Shannon)
Eva Bourne (Hannah Shannon)
Keven O’Grady (Detective Lynwood)
Johannah Newmarch (Sally Lynwood)
Jay Brazeau (Dr. Trammell)
Lochlyn Munro (Joel Jacobs)
Cory Rempel (Officer Ryan)
Terry O’Sullivan (Elizabeth Andronicus)
Jessie Fraser (Tamara Andronicus)
Lane Edwards (Lucas Andronicus)
Fred Henderson (Harvey Andronicus)
Antonio Cupo (Quin Andronicus)
Latonya Williams (Kat Ephron)
Kirby Morrow (Allan Demetry)
Samuel Patrick Chu (Zach)
Sergio Osuna (Boom Boy)
Agnes Tong (Motel Receptionist)
Bola Omodara (Officer)
Winson Won (Officer)
Rob Heschl (Lawyer)
Tracy Froese (Ava)
Krista Bell (Woman with Purse)
Ian Hawes (Auctioneer)

Divider
Based on the book series by Suzi Weinhart
Divider

Where I watched the movie: Hallmark Mystery

To see more of my reviews, go to the menu above and look under Movie and Television Reviews.

Thank you for stopping by,

Karen Signature for TV Shows (1)

Divider

Divider
Garage Sale Mysteries_ The Pandora’s Box Murders

Leave a Reply