Garage Sale Mysteries: All That Glitters

Posted August 6, 2026 by karenbaron in Book to Movie, Movie Review, Mystery, Review / 0 Comments

Format: T.V. Movie

Mysteries on the ScreenGarage Sale Mysteries_ All That GlittersGarage Sale Mysteries: All That Glitters

Network:                       Hallmark Mystery

Series Number:         2

Director:                    Peter DeLuise

Teleplay by:              Walter Klenhard

Plot Summary:

Jennifer Shannon has a gift for finding rare treasures hidden in garage sales that she can resell at her consignment store, Rags to Riches. But her keen eye for finding valuables also gets her involved in the criminal investigations that happen at the very second-hand sales she frequents. When Jennifer’s friend and self-storage facility owner, Martin, turns up murdered just hours after auctioning off an abandoned storage unit full of unique items to Jennifer, she is immediately pulled into the case as a key eyewitness. Working with Detective Lynwood, Jennifer helps identify a disgruntled customer as the prime suspect while she and her business partner, Danielle, sift through boxes from the auction. As her husband, Jason, worries about her safety, Jennifer starts to get her head in the game after a break-in at her store and a run-in with Martin’s angry wife. Then, Jennifer and Danielle discover their new merchandise contains the sparkly evidence they needed all along to nail the surprising real culprit. They must race to save a life and put their own on the line. Will they succeed before time runs out?

Divider

My Rating:

five-stars

My Thoughts:

I have always liked watching the Garage Sale Mystery movies, so I am glad that they are back.

Jennifer has a knack not only for finding a good buy at any sale she and Dani happen to find, but also, sadly, for finding dead bodies. Dani is good at making sales and talking customers into buying from their consignment shop. Dani is also good at keeping Jennifer from getting into too much trouble with her investigating. I love this duo a lot.

Garage Sale Mysteries_ All That Glitters CWThe other thing that I love is being reminded of how simple text messages looked and how the emojis have evolved over the years, from looking as simple as they do in the show to what they look like now. I love seeing Jennifer’s relationship with her family and how, even though Jason isn’t happy with what Jennifer is doing, he doesn’t try to stop her. Her relationship with her son is also awesome to see.

The killer had me guessing on who they could be, but I had a feeling of who did it. Mostly because of how they were acting around the two sleuths. I am impressed with how Jennifer figured out who did it, and with Dani, too.

Overall, I really liked this movie, and my mom and stepdad did too. He didn’t complain too much about us watching this movie again.

Divider

All That Glitters Pics

Divider

Cast:

Lori Loughlin (Jennifer Shannon)
Sarah Strange (Dani)
Steve Bacic (Jason Shannon)
Brendan Meyer (Logan Shannon)
Keven O’Grady (Detective Lynwood)
Michael Kopsa (Martin)
Johannah Newmarch (Sally Lynwood)
Marcus Rosner (Tim)
Manny Jacinto (Sam)
Christopher Ang (Officer)
Karin Konoval (Louise)
Manoj Sood (Jewelry Store Manager)
Claire Torrance (Allie)
Alison Wandzura (Wendy)
Isis Wright (Madison)
Kavan Smith (Alan Bernard/Derrick Brooks)
Kwesi Ameyaw (Cop)
Tim Bissett (Winthrop)
Crystal Campbell (Auctioneer)
Jennifer Copping (Maryanne)
Johnny Cuthbert (Angry Man)
Noel Johansen (Vern)
Aidan Kahn (Bidder)
John R. Taylor (Henry)

Divider
Based on the book series by Suzi Weinhart
Divider

Where I watched the movie: Hallmark Mystery

To see more of my reviews, go to the menu above and look under Movie and Television Reviews.

Thank you for stopping by,

Karen Signature for TV Shows (1)

Divider

Divider
Garage Sale Mysteries_ All That Glitters

Leave a Reply