Garage Sale Mysteries: A Case of Murder

Posted September 13, 2026 by karenbaron in Book to Movie, Movie Review, Mystery, Review / 0 Comments

Format: T.V. Movie

Mysteries on the ScreenGarage Sale Mysteries_ A Case of MurderGarage Sale Mysteries: A Case of Murder

Network:                       Hallmark Mystery

Series Number:         11

Director:                    Neill Fearnley

Teleplay by:              Kraig Wenman

Plot Summary:

Jenn buys an old reel-to-reel recorder at a garage sale, only to find it contains the voice of a man pleading for his life. When the former owner of the recorder, a retired therapist, is found murdered in a patient’s apartment, Jenn’s investigation leads to other patients whose love lives are more entangled than she was first led to believe.

Divider

My Rating:

four-stars

My Thoughts:

This one was quite a doozy for Jen and Detective Lynwood. Jen and Dani are a bit taken aback since they bought the tape recorder at an estate sale for the store. Although who knows how long it would have taken them to find the body if it hadn’t been for Jen.

The Shannon family is also renovating their house. Well, mostly for just one room. Jason and Logan decide to make a room in the basement as a man cave. I love how the room turned out.

I liked this movie. I was saddened by some of the outcomes, but at least most of the characters got a happy ending.

Divider

A Case of Murder Pics

Divider

Cast:

Lori Loughlin (Jennifer Shannon)
Sarah Strange (Dani)
Steve Bacic (Jason Shannon)
Connor Stanhope (Logan Shannon)
Eva Bourne (Hannah Shannon)
Keven O’Grady (Detective Lynwood)
Johannah Newmarch (Sally Lynwood)
Jay Brazeau (Dr. Trammell)
Matthew Harrison (Drew Forster)
Malcolm Stewart (Dr. Vedders)
Sarah-Jane Redmond (Mae Vedders)
Preston Vanderslice (Callum)
Lisa Durupt (Kendahl Hartman)
Derek Hamilton (Chris Suddon)
Charles Zuckermann (Darren)
Paloma Kwiatkowski (Deb Macbeth)
Tyson Bellusci (Gym Guy)
Mark Brandon (Player Guy)
Andrew Barber (Nervous Guy)
Krystle Dos Santos (Host)
Marika Siewert (Travel Agent)
Arthur Lee Rose (Sheriff)
Charles Jarman (New Doctor)

Divider
Based on the book series by Suzi Weinhart
Divider

Where I watched the movie: Hallmark Mystery

To see more of my reviews, go to the menu above and look under Movie and Television Reviews.

Thank you for stopping by,

Karen Signature for TV Shows (1)

Divider

Divider
Garage Sale Mysteries_ Murder Most Medieval