Garage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders

Posted August 29, 2026 by karenbaron in Book to Movie, Movie Review, Mystery, Review / 0 Comments

Format: T.V. Movie

Mysteries on the ScreenGarage Sale Mysteries_ The Novel MurdersGarage Sale Mysteries: The Novel Murders

Network:                       Hallmark Mystery

Series Number:         6

Director:                    Norma Bailey

Teleplay by:              Walter Klenhard

Plot Summary:

Jennifer Shannon is a garage-sale shopping expert whose sharp observational skills allow her to uncover valuable antiques and help her local police department investigate crimes and solve mysteries. When an impoverished man enters Rags to Riches – a consignment shop where Jennifer sells the gems she’s found at garage sales – and asks to have an item home-delivered, Jennifer agrees. Upon her arrival at his run-down apartment, Jennifer finds the man murdered. As the police survey the crime scene, Jennifer cannot help but think there is something familiar about the details of the killing – and soon realizes that the victim’s cold-blooded demise is a re-enactment of a murder in a classic mystery novel.

Divider

My Rating:

five-stars

My Thoughts:

Jennifer doesn’t mean to stumble upon dead bodies, but she just can’t help but end up solving the mystery. In this movie, she becomes a consultant for the police because of her knowledge of mysteries. The murders also resemble those in different books, and Detective Lynnwood asks Jen for her help.Garage Sale Mysteries The Novel Murders CW

I have to say that this movie was a good one. It had me guessing who could have done it, but I was thinking I knew who did it from about the middle of the movie. Even if I wasn’t sure about why. Actually, I still have no clue why the person who did it really did it. The main reason is that I thought the reasoning was a bit sketchy once it was revealed, but what do I know.

The family moments are what saved this movie for me since I thought the mystery was cool until it was revealed who did it. But Jen’s family really pulled it together, as that is something I like seeing in these movies. Jason and Logan had some son-and-father bonding moments without Logan being on or holding an electronic device. That left Jennifer and Hannah with some girl-bonding time.

This story was good even if I thought the mystery was a bit odd at the end. Despite that, I loved every moment of this movie, and I can’t wait to see what happens next. The two things I like most are the Shannon family moments and the dinner parties Jen throws. The guests are always amazing.

Divider

The Novel Murders Pics

Divider

Cast:

Lori Loughlin (Jennifer Shannon)
Sarah Strange (Dani)
Steve Bacic (Jason Shannon)
Connor Stanhope (Logan Shannon)
Eva Bourne (Hannah Shannon)
Keven O’Grady (Detective Lynwood)
Peter Hanlon (Dr. Blake)
Ken Tremblett (Terrance Duncan)
Gerard Plunkett (Professor Myles Fowler)
Alex Zahara (McNally)
Fiona Vroom (Maggie)
Barbara Wallace (Clara)
John Innes (Art Henley)
Benita Ha (Book Clerk)
Steve Elliott (Client)
Jason Cermak (Cop #1)
Jessica Heafey (Cop #2)
Ronald Patrick Thompson (Cop #3)
Bronwen Smith (Detective)
Christine Lippa (Laura)
Mig Macario (Loan Officer)
Cameron Park (Man)
Anne Openshaw (Operator)
Gary Peterman (Oscar)
Celeste Insell (Shirley)
Katey Hoffman (Terri)
John Stewart (Tony)
Maggie Phillips (Waitress)
Brittany Mitchell (Woman)

Divider
Based on the book series by Suzi Weinhart
Divider

Where I watched the movie: Hallmark Mystery

All photos are courtesy of Crown Media. To see more of my reviews, go to the menu above and look under Movie and Television Reviews.

Thank you for stopping by,

Karen Signature for TV Shows (1)

Divider

Divider
Garage Sale Mysteries_ The Novel Murders

Leave a Reply